Why Customer Success Should Own Renewals And Sales Should Never Touch Them Again

In partnership with

Read time: 3 minutes.

Welcome to the 201th edition of The Growth Elements Newsletter. Every Monday and sometimes on Thursday, I write an essay on growth metrics & experiments and business case studies.

Today’s piece is for 8,000+ founders, operators, and leaders from businesses such as Shopify, Google, Hubspot, Zoho, Freshworks, Servcorp, Zomato, Postman, Razorpay and Zoom.

Today’s The Growth Elements (TGE) is brought to you by:

The ops hire that onboards in 30 seconds.

Viktor is an AI coworker that lives in Slack, right where your team already works.

Message Viktor like a teammate: "pull last quarter's revenue by channel," or "build a dashboard for our board meeting."

Viktor connects to your tools, does the work, and delivers the actual report, spreadsheet, or dashboard. Not a summary. The real thing.

There’s no new software to adopt and no one to train.

Most teams start with one task. Within a week, Viktor is handling half of their ops.

Add Viktor to Slack for free.

^{Thank you for supporting our sponsors, who keep this newsletter free.}

Most B2B SaaS companies have renewal ownership backwards.

• Sales closes the deal.

• Customer Success manages the relationship.

• Then, at renewal time, Sales swoops back in to "protect the contract.”

The result?

• Customer feels sold twice.

• CS feels undermined.

• And your renewal rate quietly suffers.

The Real Problem With Sales-Owned Renewals

• Sales reps are incentivised on new revenue renewals are an afterthought, not a priority.

• When Sales re-enters at renewal, it signals to the customer that the relationship was transactional all along.

• CS has spent 11 months building trust, then hands over the most important conversation to someone the customer barely knows.

• Renewals handled by Sales take longer to close, require more negotiation, and result in higher churn rates.

Data point: Companies where CS owns renewals see 15-20% higher renewal rates than those where Sales leads the process.

Why Most Founders Haven't Made the Switch

[1] They confuse renewal with upsell

• Renewal is about retention, confirming existing value, and securing continuity.

• Upsell is about expansion, introducing new value, and growing the account.

• These are two different conversations, each requiring a different owner.

CS is built for retention. Sales is built for expansion. Stop mixing them up.

[2] They don't trust CS to "close"

This is a skills problem, not a structural one.

• CS teams that own renewals need commercial training on how to handle pricing pushback, how to reframe value, and how to create urgency.

• The fix is to invest in CS capability, not to hand the conversation back to Sales.

[3] They haven't defined the handoff clearly

• The rule is simple: CS owns the renewal. Sales enters only when there is a genuine expansion opportunity.

• No expansion opportunity? Sales stay out. Full stop.

• Document this. Put it in your CRM. Make it a process, not a judgment call.

What the Switch Actually Looks Like

[1] CS owns renewal from Day 1, not Day 330

• Renewal conversations should start 90 days before expiry not 30.

• CS should be documenting value delivered throughout the year so the renewal conversation is a summary, not a pitch.

[2] Build a renewal playbook inside CS

• Standardise the renewal motion: value review > ROI summary > pricing conversation > close.

• Give CS the commercial language and objection handles they need to do this confidently.

[3] Sales gets credit for the expansion only

• Restructure your comp model so Sales is incentivised on net new and expansion, not on renewals they didn't earn.

• This removes the political fight over account ownership and aligns incentives correctly.

Final Words

Renewals are not a sales event. They are the result of 12 months of CS work. The team that built the relationship should close it. Fix the ownership. Fix the incentives. The renewal rate will follow.

[1] Audit who owns your renewals today and what your renewal close rate actually is.

[2] Define the clear line between renewal (CS) and expansion (Sales).

[3] Build the commercial capability in your CS team to own that conversation with confidence.​

That's it for today's article! I hope you found this essay insightful.

Wishing you a productive week ahead!

I always appreciate you reading.

Thanks,
Chintankumar Maisuria